site logo
ARRS InPractice
  • Latest Issue
  • Contact Us
Homepage > Articles > Winter 2020 > In-the-Moment Aggressions

In-the-Moment Aggressions

10/2/12 2012 Radiology faculty.
avatar

Ruth C. Carlos
2019–2020 ARRS President

    Here’s a word that you still won’t find in Stedman’s: microaggression. A short, often casual exchange that, regardless of intent, can send a disparaging message to a certain individual because of group membership, there’s nothing particularly new about it. Lest you think this word was forged in a social media storm, in fact, it was a tenured professor of education and psychiatry at Harvard Medical School who first used it. Coined in 1970 by Chester M. Pierce, the first African-American full professor at Massachusetts General Hospital, to combine the subtle dismissals and outright injustice non-black Americans inflict upon African Americans, today’s wider term applies to any routine marginalization based on race, gender, sexuality, age, ability, or socioeconomic status. As Meridith J. Englander and Susan K. O’Horo observed in last October’s AJR Journal Club, microaggression has “entered our everyday vernacular”.

    Need the word in a sentence, with some real-life examples? When an attending physician tells an international student that he or she is doing exceptionally well on rounds, “especially considering their background.” The subordinate or colleague who keeps hearing that they’re “just too pretty” or “far too handsome” to be stuck in a dark reading room.

    “Think of microaggressions like mosquito bites,” wrote Carolynn M. DeBenedectis, lead author of “Microaggression in Radiology,” the September commentary published in the Journal of the American College of Radiology. “A single or occasional mosquito bite is annoying for a second but can be ignored, but when the mosquito bites are unrelenting and in large numbers, they can be damaging.” Left untreated, these bites of bias— again, unconscious or not—can lead to diminished self-confidence, poorer self-image, as well as serious mental health conditions like anxiety and depression.

    Responding to the August commentary in JAMA Pediatrics, the New York Times’ headline wondered, “Is it possible to train doctors without hurting anyone’s feelings?”. Of course, as JAMA’s own title duly noted, “Avoiding the eggshells is not the answer”. We practice medicine, and sooner rather than later, all practicing diagnostic radiologists will have to render a difficult face-in-PACS decision and engage in a potentially problematic discussion face-to-face. For academic and mentor radiologists alike, it’s our duty to point out the mistakes of others—shedding light on each artifact and every pitfall.

    Acknowledging that a person’s gender, ethnicity, or circumstances are real-world facts, how should we respond as the “other?” Moreover, what does a true ally do in these most fraught moments? To start, always consider the source, where context remains key. Being too brusque helps neither party, especially if the microaggressor is closely connected to the microaggrieved. “Keep the initial conversation short, and schedule a time to talk about it later to give the other person time to think things over,” suggests NiCole T. Buchanan, an associate professor of psychology who leads workshops on microaggressions at Michigan State University.

    At the same time, passive-aggressiveness can hurt everyone, beyond the microaggressor and the microaggrieved even. As leadership consultant Mario Rodriguez noted during this year’s Association of Medical Imaging Management annual meeting, following a simple, three-step process often helps to diffuse conflicts in a pointedly, albeit respectful manner. According to Rodriguez, “you should describe the problem simply, explain clearly how it makes you feel, and, then, outline the changes you’d like to see”.

    As Judy Melinek wrote, “social justice is good medicine”. Together, we can be both radiologist and advocate.


    The opinions expressed in InPractice magazine are those of the author(s); they do not necessarily reflect the viewpoint or position of the editors, reviewers, or publisher.

    Related

    Previous StoryGender Affirmation Surgery: A Primer on Imaging Correlates for the Radiologist
    Next StoryDiagnostic Radiologists with Lifetime ABR Certificates Less Likely to Participate in MOC

    ARRS

    Contact InPractice
    Meetings
    Articles with Credit
    Books / Books with Credit
    Online Courses
    Web Lectures

    AJR

    AJR Journal
    AJR Articles with Credit
    Subscribe to AJR

    ARRS Membership

    Benefits
    Join / Renew
    Volunteer Opportunities
    In-Training Radiologists
    Senior Radiologists

    Scholarships

    Donate Now
    Roentgen Fund®
    Fellowships / Awards
    Making a Difference

    The American Roentgen Ray Society (ARRS) is accredited by the Accreditation Council for Continuing Medical Education (ACCME) to provide continuing medical education activities for physicians. ARRS has been granted Deemed Status by the American Board of Radiology (ABR). Copyright ©, American Roentgen Ray Society, ARRS, All Rights Reserved.